Scripting News for 7/15/2006

Steve Gillmor: “” 

Ben Barren 

Ben is a smart mofo, that’s for sure. (As is Nick.)

I don’t know why I got a blank paragraph from Steve Gillmor, but I can guess.

Steve works for Podshow and I was very critical of Podshow, with good cause, last week.

As the people at FeedBurner can attest, business models built on centralizing RSS set my hair on fire. At least with Feedburner they do it on an opt-in basis, but even then I think people should be aware of how much power they’re giving them, and always be thinking about who owns them, and their motives, and who they might sell out to, and their motives.

In the case of Podshow, I know who they are, and have seen how ruthless they can be with other people’s work, not just mine, and how their lack of conscience means they’ll do things that I don’t want to know about, but since it’s in my area of creativity, I have to be concerned. Now Steve had his reasons for making his deal with Podshow, and I’ve never questioned those here on Scripting News, because it’s not my place to. He has a family to feed and house and kids to send to college, and honest to god, Steve is a friend of mine, and I care about him, and I don’t care what devil he makes a deal with, as long as he stays friendly.

Steve didn’t like what I said about Podshow last week. So be it. Doesn’t change what I think about what they did, it was awful, and it had to be stopped, and apparently it has stopped, and that’s good. I don’t give them the same benefit of the doubt I give others, because I have lots of experience with them. I think they meant to control our podcast feeds so they could sell position in those feeds to advertisers. I don’t think they planned to ask our permission or share revenue with us. If their intentions were truly innocent this time, I apologize, but I don’t think they were.

Next time, if they want us to believe they had good intentions, they should test the services privately before taking them public. And when they screw up, the apology should be without reservation, and without kicking those who called them on their mistake. If Steve Gillmor thinks I’m fucked up for calling them on it, Steve can think that, no one is perfect, not even Steve.đŸ™‚

One response to this post.

  1. Although I can’t claim to have the same degree of familiarity with those in control of Podshow as Dave can, I was involved (in a small way) with iPodder.org “in the early” days. As a result I was privy to statements made about communal involvement and “partying together” and other like “flourishes” during the period just before it became patently obvious that podcasting was going to take off.

    Frankly, and as Dave knows I was publically critical of Dave and Adam when they starting making pronouncements about starting a “for profit.” Not because I’m anti-profit but because what little of their plans were made public didn’t seem to jibe at least in spirit with much of what had transpired in prior months.

    However and as history shows, Dave parted company with those who later founded Podshow, as their plans increasingly diverged from statements during the early ramp-up of podcasting and rapid growth of iPodder.org.

    It was at this point, at least for me, that it became clear to me who made good on all of the statements made previously and who was ready to jettison those statements in search of more narrow personal gain.

    The point that I wish to emphasis is that with regard to Dave’s post above, I can attest based on personal experience to the fact that Dave has good reason to approach Podshow’s actions with a healthy dose of sckepticism and to support the notion that you should too!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: